Black Narcissus (1947) is, wait for it, MY FAVOURITE FILM OF ALL TIME! “How is this possible?” you say. Let me explain.
It was written, directed and produced by ‘the Archers’, Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger. Oh, you want more? I don’t know, that should be enough for anyone! But why then not The Red Shoes or The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp? Well, those two do feature in my top 100, Blimp quite highly, but in Black Narcissus I find everything I want. Those things include the nostalgia inherent in picking an ‘old’ movie rather than a modern one. It’s only as films age that they acquire perfect taste. I’m not going to say anything about wine – don’t worry.

I suppose the thing that stands out most obviously is the subject matter. Name me one other film where ‘nuns go mad in the Himylayas’. So its striking in its obtuseness to begin with. The story seems wafer thin in that not a great deal seems to happen and when it does it doesn’t seem to amount to very much, except for the fact that it does! Watching this as a child I fell in love with this on the basis that it was just had a fantastic thriller ‘ending’ – a life and death struggle between two nuns at that! Now of course the many layers of sexuality and repressed desire strike me most agreeably.
Add to that photography by Jack Cardiff against which many a master painter of old fades into insignificance. Rarely a film of that age where almost every single frame could live quite easily as a print on the living room wall. The matte paintings that lead you to fully accept that Wales is somewhere in Asia are still astonishing. Maybe not entirely believable, but still astonishing.
Still not convinced. I refer you to the scene where Kathleen Bryon applies her lipstick, in ultra close-up, not for the first time in her life one thinks. For me that is probably the high point of the medium itself! Within that scene notice the bravura editing and movement, truly painting with light. For more chills again with Kathleen Byron her reappearance at the door as Deborah Kerr tugs at the bell rope. There isn’t anything in the Exorcist to approach that for the sudden realisation of a purely evil intent.
OK, it’s not all sex and horror! There are some amazing scenes in flashback of Deborah Kerr’s life before her character Sister Ruth joins the order. Dazzling colour to shame the pre-raphaelites! And David Farrar as the love interest? Well, speaking as a straight man, and that’s pretty straight as the English go, I almost fell in love with him myself. Having him ride around on the smallest of ponies does nothing to diminish his mystique and the final shot of him in the rain looking after the one thing he cannot have and brushing his hair back in the most manly of manly ways is simply magnificent. And I don’t give a hoot how that sounds!
Is that enough? I’ve not mentioned countless favourite scenes. Or even Flora Robson. Or Sabu. “3pm to 4pm, physics with the physical Sister!” Or Jean Simmons! Or my favourite line of dialogue in any movie ever – “I DON’T LOVE ANYONE!”
As a final note I’d just like to say that if you haven’t seen a decent print of this film then you’ve not seen it at all. I caught a version on cable that was barely watchable. I think this is out or soon to be out on Blu-ray soon. Get that. Or the Critereon DVD version I’ve got with all the really great extras on it.
There is an absolute wealth of information out there on this film if you look hard enough and I’ve discovered a few new tidbits myself today!
Did I say this is MY FAVOURITE FILM OF ALL TIME?